12 Movies Like When the Lights Went Out You Need to Watch
Craving eerie horror and mystery picks? Explore 12 chilling films with haunted houses, dark secrets, and suspenseful twists to watch next.
If you want movies like When the Lights Went Out, this roundup leans into haunted-house dread, eerie secrets, and the kind of tension that keeps you checking the dark corners of the room. You’ll find modern shocks and slow-burn scares here, from The Conjuring and The Amityville Horror to the nerve-rattling claustrophobia of Silent House and the supernatural unease of Insidious: The Last Key. There’s also a darker, more folkloric streak in May the Devil Take You, plus sharp mystery-driven picks like The Pact and I Trapped the Devil. Whether you’re here for ghost stories, psychological suspense, or a blend of horror and mystery, these titles deliver the same unsettled feeling in different ways.
-
01
May the Devil Take You
horror · mystery · thriller
Hoping to find answers to her estranged father's mysterious illness, a young woman visits his old villa and uncovers a horrifying truth from the past.
Directed by Timo TjahjantoCast Chelsea Islan, Pevita Pearce, Ray Sahetapy, Karina Suwandhi, Samo RafaelNetflix -
02
The Pact
horror · mystery · thriller
After their mother passes away, sisters Nicole and Annie reluctantly return to their childhood home to pay their last respects. While staying overnight in the house, the sisters sense a mysterious presence in their midst: noises startling them in the night, objects moving about, a fallen picture of an unknown woman posed next to their mother. Annie begins experiencing a series of intense and disturbing dreams - visions that lead her to uncover something terrible about her mother's past that is finally revealing itself.
Directed by Nicholas McCarthyCast Caity Lotz, Kathleen Rose Perkins, Haley Hudson, Sam Ball, Mark StegerAMC+ -
03
The Conjuring
horror · mystery · thriller
Paranormal investigators Ed and Lorraine Warren work to help a family terrorized by a dark presence in their farmhouse. Forced to confront a powerful entity, the Warrens find themselves caught in the most terrifying case of their lives.
Directed by James WanCast Vera Farmiga, Patrick Wilson, Lili Taylor, Ron Livingston, Shanley CaswellMax -
04
Insidious: The Last Key
horror · mystery · thriller
Parapsychologist Elise Rainier and her team travel to Five Keys, NM, to investigate a man’s claim of a haunting. Terror soon strikes when Rainier realizes that the house he lives in was her family’s old home.
Directed by Adam RobitelCast Lin Shaye, Leigh Whannell, Angus Sampson, Kirk Acevedo, Kit GoldsmithMax -
05
Silent House
horror · thriller
Sarah returns with her father and uncle to fix up the family's longtime summerhouse after it was violated by squatters in the off-season. As they work in the dark, Sarah begins to hear sounds from within the walls of the boarded-up building. Although she barely remembers the place, Sarah senses the past may still haunt the home.
Directed by Chris Kentis, Laura LauCast Elizabeth Olsen, Adam Trese, Eric Sheffer Stevens, Julia Chan, Adam BarnettAmazon Prime Video -
06
I Trapped the Devil
horror · mystery · thriller
A man descends into paranoia after trapping what he believes to be the devil in his basement, but things take a dark turn when his family unexpectedly arrive for Christmas.
Directed by Josh LoboCast Scott Poythress, AJ Bowen, Susan Burke, Rowan Russell, John MarrottAMC+ -
07
The Amityville Horror
horror
George Lutz, his wife Kathy, and their three children have just moved into a beautiful, and improbably cheap, Dutch colonial mansion nestled in the sleepy coastal town of Amityville, Long Island. However, their dream home is concealing a horrific past and soon each member of the Lutz family is plagued with increasingly strange and violent visions and impulses.
Directed by Andrew DouglasCast Ryan Reynolds, Melissa George, Jesse James, Jimmy Bennett, Chloë Grace MoretzAMC+ -
08
The Enfield Poltergeist
documentary · horror
Experience the chilling true story of the world's most famous poltergeist case through original audio recordings made inside the house as the events unfolded.
Directed by Jerry RothwellCast Olivia Booth-Ford, Christopher Ettridge, Paula Benson, Charlotte Miller, Daniel LeeApple TV Plus -
09
May the Devil Take You Too
fantasy · horror · mystery · thriller
Two years after escaping from demonic terror, a young woman is still haunted by unnatural vision. The dangers that await her and her friends are increasingly threatening.
Directed by Timo TjahjantoCast Chelsea Islan, Widika Darsih Sidmore, Baskara Mahendra, Hadijah Shahab, LuteshaAMC+ -
10
Sinister
horror · mystery · thriller
True-crime writer Ellison Oswald is in a slump; he hasn't had a best seller in more than 10 years and is becoming increasingly desperate for a hit. So, when he discovers the existence of a snuff film showing the deaths of a family, he vows to solve the mystery. He moves his own family into the victims' home and gets to work. However, when old film footage and other clues hint at the presence of a supernatural force, Ellison learns that living in the house may be fatal.
Directed by Scott DerricksonCast Ethan Hawke, Juliet Rylance, Fred Thompson, James Ransone, Michael Hall D'AddarioHuluPeacock Premium -
11
Red Lights
drama · fantasy · mystery
Two investigators of paranormal hoaxes, the veteran Dr. Margaret Matheson and her young assistant, Tom Buckley, study the most varied metaphysical phenomena with the aim of proving their fraudulent origins. Simon Silver, a legendary blind psychic, reappears after an enigmatic absence of 30 years to become the greatest international challenge to both orthodox science and professional sceptics. Tom starts to develop an intense obsession with Silver, whose magnetism becomes stronger with each new manifestation of inexplicable events. As Tom gets closer to Silver, tension mounts, and his worldview is threatened to its core.
Directed by Rodrigo CortésCast Cillian Murphy, Sigourney Weaver, Robert De Niro, Toby Jones, Joely RichardsonAmazon Prime Video -
12
Dark Touch
horror
Niamh is the lone survivor of a mysterious massacre in which the furniture and objects in her family’s isolated house took on a monstrous life of their own. The police ignore her wild stories, and the neighbours and social worker who take her into their care try to introduce her to a new life. But Niamh is unable to leave her violent past behind her, endangering everyone who crosses her path.
Directed by Marina de VanCast Missy Keating, Marcella Plunkett, Pádraic Delaney, Charlotte Flyvholm, Steve WallAMC+
Wrapping Up
This list is built for anyone chasing the same creepy mood, haunted setting, and jumpy tension that made the original stand out. From true-blue paranormal scares to mystery-heavy thrillers, each pick brings its own version of fear without losing that uneasy, late-night vibe. Save this page and come back when you want another round of unsettling recommendations, because it’s updated regularly with fresh matches and new additions. If you’re planning your next horror marathon, this is a solid place to start.
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes these movies similar to When the Lights Went Out?
These picks were matched by tone, themes, and story style using a similarity model trained on plot synopses, genres, and cast — not just shared genre tags — so the connection runs deeper than a simple category match.
Related Guides
Last updated: September 8, 2026