12 Movies Like Supernatural You Need to Watch
Find 12 eerie, suspenseful picks for fans of Supernatural, from Constantine and Medium to Hemlock Grove, Heroes, and more genre-fueled favorites.
If you’re searching for movies like Supernatural, you’re probably after the same mix of eerie cases, dark mythology, and characters who keep going when the odds turn ugly. This list leans into that mood with picks such as Constantine, The Vampire Diaries, Medium, and Being Human, each bringing its own blend of drama, fantasy, horror, mystery, and thriller energy. You’ll also find more serialized favorites like Heroes, Hemlock Grove, and A Haunting, which keep the suspense high and the tone atmospheric. Whether you want ghost stories, occult investigations, or power struggles with a supernatural twist, these titles deliver that familiar tension without feeling repetitive. It’s a strong starting point for anyone who likes their genre stories a little moody, a little strange, and easy to binge.
-
01
The Vampire Diaries
drama · fantasy · horror · mystery · romance · thriller
The story of two vampire brothers obsessed with the same girl, who bears a striking resemblance to the beautiful but ruthless vampire they knew and loved in 1864.
Directed by Chris Grismer, Joshua Butler, Michael A. Allowitz, Marcos Siega, Pascal VerschoorisCast Paul Wesley, Ian Somerhalder, Kat Graham, Candice King, Zach RoerigPeacock PremiumMax -
02
Heroes
crime · drama · fantasy · mystery · sci-fi · thriller
Common people discover that they have super powers. Their lives intertwine as a devastating event must be prevented.
Directed by Greg Beeman, Allan Arkush, Jeannot Szwarc, Adam Kane, Greg YaitanesCast Jack Coleman, Hayden Panettiere, Milo Ventimiglia, Masi Oka, Sendhil RamamurthyNetflix -
03
Medium
crime · drama · fantasy · mystery · thriller
Allison Dubois works in the District Attorney’s office using her natural intuition about people and her ability to communicate with the dead to help to solve crimes. Her dreams often give her clues to the whereabouts of missing people.
Directed by Aaron Lipstadt, Peter Werner, Vincent Misiano, Arlene Sanford, Larry TengCast Patricia Arquette, Miguel Sandoval, Sofia Vassilieva, Jake Weber, Feodor LarkParamount Plus -
04
Constantine
action · fantasy · horror · mystery
John Constantine has literally been to Hell and back. When he teams up with a policewoman to solve the mysterious suicide of her twin sister, their investigation takes them through the world of demons and angels that exists beneath the landscape of contemporary Los Angeles.
Directed by Francis LawrenceCast Keanu Reeves, Rachel Weisz, Shia LaBeouf, Djimon Hounsou, Max BakerMax -
05
Hemlock Grove
drama · fantasy · horror · mystery · sci-fi · thriller
One cannot quench his all-consuming thirst. The other cannot tame the beast clawing its way out. In the sleepy Pennsylvania village of Hemlock Grove, two young men struggle to accept painful truths: about family, themselves, the mystery of the White Tower - and a terrifying new threat so powerful it will turn them from predators into prey.
Directed by David Straiton, Deran Sarafian, Russell Lee Fine, T.J. Scott, David SemelCast Famke Janssen, Bill Skarsgård, Landon Liboiron, Joel de la Fuente, Kaniehtiio HornPeacock PremiumAMC+ -
06
A Haunting
drama · fantasy · horror · mystery · reality-tv · thriller
These are the true stories of the innocent and the unimaginable. Based on true events, A Haunting dramatises some of the scariest stories, revealing a world in which tragedy, suicide and murder have left psychic impressions so powerful that innocent people become forced to deal with them decades later. Through mesmerizing first-person accounts, the mystery and origin of each haunting is powerfully revealed and leaves a lingering sense that life—and death—are much stronger then anyone could have possibly imagined.
Directed by David Haycox, Greg Francis, Jeffrey Fine, Stuart Taylor, Lance CataniaCast Andrew Ragan, Kelley Davis, Terry Jernigan, Doug Haupt, Tony WadeAmazon Prime VideoPeacock PremiumFreeveeMax -
07
Being Human
comedy · drama · fantasy · horror
Deciding to turn over a new leaf, a group of friends who also happen to be vampires and werewolves move into a house together, only to find that it is haunted by ghosts of people who have been killed under mysterious circumstances. As they deal with the challenges of being supernatural creatures, their desire to be human bonds them.
Directed by Philip John, Colin Teague, Daniel O'Hara, Charles Martin, Toby HaynesCast Lenora Crichlow, Russell Tovey, Aidan Turner, Sinéad Keenan, Michael SochaAmazon Prime VideoPeacock PremiumAMC+Freevee -
08
South of Hell
drama · fantasy · horror · thriller
A supernatural thriller set in South Carolina, South Of Hell focuses on Maria Abascal (Suvari), a stunning demon-hunter-for-hire whose power stems from within. Like those she hunts, Maria is divided within herself, struggling with her own demon, Abigail, who resides inside of her, feeding on the evil Maria exorcises from others. Maria and Abigail share a soul and a destiny, but as Maria desperately tries to overtake Abigail, she will discover how far Abigail will go to remain a part of her.
Directed by Jeremiah S. Chechik, Jennifer Lynch, Rachel Talalay, Eli Roth, Ti WestCast Mena Suvari, Zachary Booth, Lamman Rucker, Paulina Singer, Drew MoerleinFreevee -
09
Ghost Whisperer
drama · fantasy
Newlywed Melinda Gordon tries to help the dead communicate with loved ones, but sometimes the messages she receives are intense and confusing. Most of Melinda's efforts involve resolving conflicts that are preventing the spirits from passing over.
Directed by Ian Sander, Eric Laneuville, John Gray, Peter Werner, Gloria MuzioCast Jennifer Love Hewitt, David Conrad, Camryn Manheim, Christoph Sanders, Jamie KennedyAmazon Prime Video -
10
Apostle
drama · fantasy · horror · mystery · thriller
In 1905, a man travels to a remote island in search of his missing sister who has been kidnapped by a mysterious religious cult.
Directed by Gareth EvansCast Dan Stevens, Richard Elfyn, Paul Higgins, Bill Milner, Catrin AaronNetflix -
11
SurrealEstate
drama · fantasy · mystery · sci-fi · thriller
Real estate agent Luke Roman and his team specialize in clearing and closing haunted houses.
Directed by Danishka Esterhazy, Paolo Barzman, T.W. Peacocke, Melanie Scrofano, John VatcherCast Tim Rozon, Maurice Dean Wint, Sarah Levy, Savannah Basley, Adam KorsonHulu -
12
Demon
adventure · drama · fantasy · horror · mystery · thriller
A young priest enlists the help of a demon hunter and a paranormal expert to search for a kidnapped girl in the underworld of Mexico City.
Directed by J.M Cravioto, Rigoberto CastañedaCast Christopher Von Uckermann, Gisselle Kuri, Fátima Molina, Horacio Garcia Rojas, Humberto BustoNetflix
Wrapping Up
This collection brings together a wide range of supernatural storytelling, from haunted investigations and psychic drama to vampire lore and high-stakes mystery. If you liked the mix of suspense, character conflict, and eerie atmosphere in Supernatural, these picks give you plenty of places to go next. Bookmark this page and come back when you want another batch of genre-friendly recommendations. It’s updated regularly, so there’s always something new to explore as the list grows and shifts with fresh titles.
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes these movies similar to Supernatural?
These picks were matched by tone, themes, and story style using a similarity model trained on plot synopses, genres, and cast — not just shared genre tags — so the connection runs deeper than a simple category match.
Related Guides
Last updated: September 4, 2026