12 Best Shows Like Supernatural to Watch Next (2026)
Craving eerie TV with monsters, mysteries, and family stakes? Explore 12 picks that echo Supernatural’s mix of fantasy, horror, and suspense.
If you’re searching for shows like Supernatural, the best picks usually mix eerie mysteries, family drama, and a strong supernatural streak. This list leans into that same mood with titles such as The Vampire Diaries, Heroes, Medium, and Being Human, each offering its own twist on fantasy, horror, and suspense. You’ll also find darker, more unusual options like Hemlock Grove, South of Hell, and Helstrom for viewers who want the menace turned up. Whether you prefer ghost stories, demon hunters, or people discovering powers they never asked for, these series keep the strange and the human side by side.
-
01
The Vampire Diaries
drama · fantasy · horror · mystery · romance · thriller
The story of two vampire brothers obsessed with the same girl, who bears a striking resemblance to the beautiful but ruthless vampire they knew and loved in 1864.
Why watch: If you like supernatural drama with romance and mystery, this is an easy fit. Its vampire-centered premise gives it a darker, more personal angle while keeping the thriller side in play.
Directed by Chris Grismer, Joshua Butler, Michael A. Allowitz, Marcos Siega, Pascal VerschoorisCast Paul Wesley, Ian Somerhalder, Kat Graham, Candice King, Zach RoerigPeacock PremiumMaxMore details on IMDb → -
02
Heroes
Won 1 Emmy Outstanding Directing for a Drama Series (2007) · 14 nominations
crime · drama · fantasy · mystery · sci-fi · thriller
Common people discover that they have super powers. Their lives intertwine as a devastating event must be prevented.
Why watch: If you want power-driven storytelling with suspense and a looming disaster, this is a strong choice. The mix of crime, fantasy, mystery, sci-fi, and thriller elements gives it a broader superhero angle.
Directed by Greg Beeman, Allan Arkush, Jeannot Szwarc, Adam Kane, Greg YaitanesCast Jack Coleman, Hayden Panettiere, Milo Ventimiglia, Masi Oka, Sendhil RamamurthyNetflixTubiMore details on IMDb → -
03
Medium
Won 1 Emmy Outstanding Lead Actress in a Drama Series (2005) · 3 nominations
crime · drama · fantasy · mystery · thriller
Allison Dubois works in the District Attorney’s office using her natural intuition about people and her ability to communicate with the dead to help to solve crimes. Her dreams often give her clues to the whereabouts of missing people.
Why watch: If you enjoy stories about hidden abilities used to solve strange cases, this one should appeal to you. Its fantasy-mystery setup and focus on communicating with the dead make it feel comfortably eerie.
Directed by Aaron Lipstadt, Peter Werner, Vincent Misiano, Arlene Sanford, Larry TengCast Patricia Arquette, Miguel Sandoval, Sofia Vassilieva, Jake Weber, Feodor LarkParamount PlusMore details on IMDb → -
04
Hemlock Grove
2 Emmy nominations
drama · fantasy · horror · mystery · sci-fi · thriller
One cannot quench his all-consuming thirst. The other cannot tame the beast clawing its way out. In the sleepy Pennsylvania village of Hemlock Grove, two young men struggle to accept painful truths: about family, themselves, the mystery of the White Tower - and a terrifying new threat so powerful it will turn them from predators into prey.
Why watch: If you’re drawn to small-town stories with horror, mystery, and sci-fi tension, this is worth a look. It leans into family secrets and a threatening presence, which suits viewers who like their supernatural drama unsettling.
Directed by David Straiton, Deran Sarafian, Russell Lee Fine, T.J. Scott, David SemelCast Famke Janssen, Bill Skarsgård, Landon Liboiron, Joel de la Fuente, Kaniehtiio HornAmazon Prime VideoTubiPeacock PremiumAMC+More details on IMDb → -
05
A Haunting
drama · fantasy · horror · mystery · reality-tv · thriller
These are the true stories of the innocent and the unimaginable. Based on true events, A Haunting dramatises some of the scariest stories, revealing a world in which tragedy, suicide and murder have left psychic impressions so powerful that innocent people become forced to deal with them decades later. Through mesmerizing first-person accounts, the mystery and origin of each haunting is powerfully revealed and leaves a lingering sense that life—and death—are much stronger then anyone could have possibly imagined.
Why watch: If real-world ghost stories sound more compelling than fictional monsters, this is a good match. Its true-story framing and horror-mystery mix make it a fit for fans who like haunting cases with a documentary-style angle.
Directed by David Haycox, Greg Francis, Jeffrey Fine, Stuart Taylor, Lance CataniaCast Andrew Ragan, Kelley Davis, Terry Jernigan, Doug Haupt, Tony WadeAmazon Prime VideoTubiPeacock PremiumFreeveeMaxMore details on IMDb → -
06
Being Human
3 BAFTA TV Award nominations
comedy · drama · fantasy · horror
Deciding to turn over a new leaf, a group of friends who also happen to be vampires and werewolves move into a house together, only to find that it is haunted by ghosts of people who have been killed under mysterious circumstances. As they deal with the challenges of being supernatural creatures, their desire to be human bonds them.
Why watch: If you like supernatural setups that still leave room for humor and friendship, this one stands out. Vampires, werewolves, and ghosts share the same space here, so it may suit viewers who want a less grim take on paranormal life.
Directed by Philip John, Colin Teague, Daniel O'Hara, Charles Martin, Toby HaynesCast Lenora Crichlow, Russell Tovey, Aidan Turner, Sinéad Keenan, Michael SochaAmazon Prime VideoTubiPeacock PremiumAMC+FreeveeMore details on IMDb → -
07
South of Hell
drama · fantasy · horror · thriller
A supernatural thriller set in South Carolina, South Of Hell focuses on Maria Abascal (Suvari), a stunning demon-hunter-for-hire whose power stems from within. Like those she hunts, Maria is divided within herself, struggling with her own demon, Abigail, who resides inside of her, feeding on the evil Maria exorcises from others. Maria and Abigail share a soul and a destiny, but as Maria desperately tries to overtake Abigail, she will discover how far Abigail will go to remain a part of her.
Why watch: If you prefer a darker hunter-driven story, this may be the pick for you. The demon-hunter premise and horror-thriller blend give it a lean, supernatural edge.
Directed by Jeremiah S. Chechik, Jennifer Lynch, Rachel Talalay, Eli Roth, Ti WestCast Mena Suvari, Zachary Booth, Lamman Rucker, Paulina Singer, Drew MoerleinFreeveeMore details on IMDb → -
08
Ghost Whisperer
4 Emmy nominations
drama · fantasy
Newlywed Melinda Gordon tries to help the dead communicate with loved ones, but sometimes the messages she receives are intense and confusing. Most of Melinda's efforts involve resolving conflicts that are preventing the spirits from passing over.
Why watch: If you enjoy ghost-centered stories that focus on messages from the dead, this is a natural choice. It keeps the supernatural side intimate and emotional rather than action-heavy.
Directed by Ian Sander, Eric Laneuville, John Gray, Peter Werner, Gloria MuzioCast Jennifer Love Hewitt, David Conrad, Camryn Manheim, Christoph Sanders, Jamie KennedyAmazon Prime VideoMore details on IMDb → -
09
SurrealEstate
drama · fantasy · mystery · sci-fi · thriller
Real estate agent Luke Roman and his team specialize in clearing and closing haunted houses.
Why watch: If haunted-house cases sound more interesting than monster hunting, this series could be a great fit. Its mystery and thriller elements work well for viewers who like paranormal cleanup with a professional angle.
Directed by Danishka Esterhazy, Paolo Barzman, T.W. Peacocke, Melanie Scrofano, John VatcherCast Tim Rozon, Maurice Dean Wint, Sarah Levy, Savannah Basley, Adam KorsonHuluMore details on IMDb → -
10
Demon
adventure · drama · fantasy · horror · mystery · thriller
A young priest enlists the help of a demon hunter and a paranormal expert to search for a kidnapped girl in the underworld of Mexico City.
Why watch: If you want a search-and-rescue story with supernatural danger, this title may be for you. Its adventure, horror, and mystery mix makes it feel especially suited to fans of tense paranormal quests.
Directed by J.M Cravioto, Rigoberto CastañedaCast Christopher Von Uckermann, Gisselle Kuri, Fátima Molina, Horacio Garcia Rojas, Humberto BustoNetflixMore details on IMDb → -
11
Being Human
drama · fantasy · horror
Three paranormal roommates, a ghost, a vampire, and a werewolf, struggle to keep their dark secrets from the world, while helping each other navigate the complexities of living double lives.
Why watch: If you like supernatural roommates and stories about balancing secrets with everyday life, this is a strong pick. The ghost, vampire, and werewolf setup keeps the fantasy and horror elements front and center.
Directed by Paolo Barzman, Stefan Pleszczynski, Adam Kane, Jeff Renfroe, Charles BinaméCast Sam Witwer, Meaghan Rath, Sam Huntington, Kristen Hager, Gianpaolo VenutaAmazon Prime VideoTubiPeacock PremiumAMC+FreeveeMore details on IMDb → -
12
Helstrom
action · adventure · drama · fantasy · horror
Daimon and Ana Helstrom are the son and daughter of a mysterious and powerful serial killer. The siblings have a complicated dynamic as they track down the terrorizing worst of humanity — each with their attitude and skills.
Why watch: If you enjoy darker family-centered stories with action and horror, this one deserves a look. Its focus on siblings tracking down terrors gives it a grim, grounded hook.
Directed by Sanford Bookstaver, Anders Engström, Cherie Nowlan, Jim O'Hanlon, Michael OfferCast Tom Austen, Sydney Lemmon, Elizabeth Marvel, Ariana Guerra, June CarrylHuluMore details on IMDb →
Wrapping Up
That mix of mystery, danger, and emotional stakes is what keeps this kind of TV so easy to binge. From haunted houses in SurrealEstate to spirit communication in Ghost Whisperer, there’s a clear range here for different tastes without losing the genre thread. Bookmark this page if you want a quick way back to these picks, and check in again later since it’s updated regularly. When you’re ready for another paranormal detour, this list makes it easy to choose your next watch.
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes these shows similar to Supernatural?
These picks were matched by tone, themes, and story style using a similarity model trained on plot synopses, genres, and cast — not just shared genre tags — so the connection runs deeper than a simple category match.