12 Movies Like Up the Catalogue You Need to Watch
Find 12 sharp recommendations for fans of Up the Catalogue, with horror, comedy, mystery, documentary, and offbeat adventure picks worth streaming.
If you’re hunting for movies like Up the Catalogue, you’re probably after something that mixes offbeat humor, eerie tension, and a smart twist on familiar genres. This list pulls together twelve picks that lean into comedy, horror, adventure, mystery, and documentary energy without feeling predictable. You’ll find the darkly funny unease of Gags the Clown and Wrinkles the Clown, the strange genre-bending spirit of Nirvanna the Band the Show the Movie, and the unsettling intrigue of Behind the Monsters. Fans of atmospheric storytelling should also check out Beyond the Gates, Beneath the Light, and We Bury the Dead, along with Up the Catalogue (2024) itself if you want the closest match.
-
01
Beyond the Gates
adventure · horror
Two estranged brothers reunite at their missing father's video store to liquidate the property and sell off his assets. As they dig through the store, they find a VCR board game titled 'Beyond the Gates' that holds a connection to their father's disappearance and deadly consequences for anyone who plays it.
Directed by Jackson StewartCast Graham Skipper, Chase Williamson, Brea Grant, Barbara Crampton, Matt MercerAMC+ -
02
Wrinkles the Clown
comedy · horror · mystery
In Florida, parents can hire Wrinkles the Clown to scare their misbehaving children.
Directed by Michael Beach NicholsCast Lillian Grubbs, D.B. Lambert, Miguel BeyNetflixAmazon Prime Video -
03
Gags the Clown
comedy · horror
It's been eight days since the clown first showed up in Green Bay, WI. Now, over the course of one night, four different groups of people cross paths with the clown everyone calls "Gags" and his true intentions are finally revealed.
Directed by Adam KrauseCast Lauren Ashley Carter, Tracy Perez, Aaron Christensen, Evan Gamble, Wyatt KuetherAMC+ -
04
Behind the Monsters
documentary · horror
A docu-series exploring how Chucky, Michael Myers, Pinhead and more came to be icons of the horror genre.
Directed by Gabrielle Binkley, Anthony UroCast Bryan Forrest, Drew Leighty, Courtlan Gordon, Lennon Hobson, Jack VenturoAMC+ -
05
Beneath the Light
adventure · biography · comedy · drama · horror · thriller
A man with a haunted past takes a job repairing an abandoned lighthouse that's only reachable by boat. His feelings of isolation and uneasiness grow as he starts to see the strange apparition of a young girl that he somehow recognizes.
Directed by John BaumgartnerCast Zach Tinker, Anne McEvoy, Kieran Sitawi, Vasi Buckovska, Ana Nicolle ChavezAmazon Prime Video -
06
We Bury the Dead
horror · thriller
After a catastrophic military disaster, the dead don't just rise - they hunt. Ava searches for her missing husband, but what she finds is far more terrifying.
Directed by Zak HilditchCast Daisy Ridley, Brenton Thwaites, Mark Coles Smith, Matt Whelan, Chloe HurstHulu -
07
Nirvanna the Band the Show the Movie
adventure · comedy · sci-fi
When their plan to book a show at the Rivoli goes horribly wrong, Matt and Jay accidentally travel back to the year 2008.
Directed by Matt JohnsonCast Matt Johnson, Jay McCarrol, Ben Petrie, Ethan Eng, Michael ScottHulu -
08
Wolves Against the World
horror
Two former neo-Nazi bandmates reunite at the site of their friend's suicide for an occult battle of wills.
Directed by Quinn ArmstrongCast Michael Kunicki, Quinn Armstrong, Jordan Mullins, Jim Azelvandre, Louie KurtzmanAmazon Prime VideoFreevee -
09
Support the Girls
comedy · drama
Lisa Conroy is general manager at a highway-side 'sports bar with curves', Double Whammies. She nurtures and protects her employees fiercely - but over the course of one trying day, her optimism is battered from every direction. Double Whammies sells a big, weird American fantasy, but what happens when reality pokes a bunch of holes in it?
Directed by Andrew BujalskiCast Regina Hall, Haley Lu Richardson, Dylan Gelula, Zoe Graham, Ann McCaskeyAmazon Prime Video -
10
May the Devil Take You
horror · mystery · thriller
Hoping to find answers to her estranged father's mysterious illness, a young woman visits his old villa and uncovers a horrifying truth from the past.
Directed by Timo TjahjantoCast Chelsea Islan, Pevita Pearce, Ray Sahetapy, Karina Suwandhi, Samo RafaelNetflix -
11
Killington
comedy · horror
During a getaway to Killington, VT, a wellness influencer's weekend retreat with her Manhattan friends takes a sinister turn as tensions rise, and the creepy locals add to the unnerving atmosphere.
Directed by Mark Dudzinski, Frank Perz, Matt VitaCast Sophie Sumner, Sarah Faye Beard, Nikki MacCallum, Brianna Cala, Sam MoralesFreevee -
12
Sorry About the Demon
comedy · horror
A young man struggling with a broken heart learns that his new place is full of restless spirits.
Directed by Emily HaginsCast Jon Michael Simpson, Jeff McQuitty, Olivia Ducayen, Paige Evans, Dave PeniukAMC+
Wrapping Up
The best part of this roundup is the range: some titles are funny, some are creepy, and some drift into the strange territory that makes a movie stick with you after the credits. Whether you want a found-footage-style chill, a documentary angle, or a weird little adventure with personality, there’s plenty here to explore. Bookmark this page and come back when you want a fresh recommendation that fits your mood. We update it regularly, so the lineup stays useful as new titles arrive.
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes these movies similar to Up the Catalogue?
These picks were matched by tone, themes, and story style using a similarity model trained on plot synopses, genres, and cast — not just shared genre tags — so the connection runs deeper than a simple category match.
Related Guides
Last updated: September 10, 2026