20 Best Mystery TV Shows on Amazon Prime Video 2026
Find the best mystery TV shows on Amazon Prime Video, from Columbo and Hannibal to The Lincoln Lawyer, with ratings, genres, and quick picks.
If you’re searching for the best mystery TV shows on Amazon Prime Video, this list gives you a strong mix of crime dramas, eerie thrillers, and darker genre picks to fit different moods. You’ll find tense, puzzle-driven titles like The Lincoln Lawyer, Person of Interest, and Columbo, plus more unsettling options such as Hannibal, Yellowjackets, and Supernatural. There’s also room for animated and anthology-style choices, including Batman: The Animated Series, Over the Garden Wall, and Creepshow. Whether you want a smart investigation, a supernatural edge, or something that keeps the clues coming, these picks make it easy to find your next watch.
-
01
Carrie
drama · horror · mystery & thriller
Misfit teenager Carrie White has spent her life in seclusion with her domineering mother, Margaret. After her father's sudden death, Carrie finds herself contending with the challenges of attending public high school, a bullying scandal, and the emergence of mysterious telekinetic powers.
Why watch: If you like mystery mixed with horror and drama, Carrie may fit well thanks to its telekinetic premise and bullying storyline. It leans into psychological tension rather than a straightforward case-of-the-week setup.
Directed by Mike Flanagan, Axelle Carolyn, Hiromi Kamata, Kyra Sedgwick, Kate SiegelCast Summer H. Howell, Samantha Sloyan, Siena Agudong, Alison Thornton, Joel OuletteAmazon Prime VideoFreeveeMore details on IMDb → -
02
The Rainmaker
crime · drama · mystery & thriller
Fresh out of law school, Rudy Baylor goes head to head with courtroom lion Leo Drummond as well as his law school girlfriend, Sarah. Rudy, along with his boss, Bruiser, and her disheveled paralegal, Deck, uncovers two connected conspiracies surrounding the mysterious death of their client's son.
Why watch: If you enjoy legal dramas with a mystery at the center, The Rainmaker could be a good match. Its crime and thriller elements suggest a story built around uncovering connected conspiracies.
Directed by Russell Lee Fine, Randy Zisk, Michael SeitzmanCast Milo Callaghan, Lana Parrilla, Madison Iseman, P.J. Byrne, Wade BriggsAmazon Prime VideoPeacock PremiumMore details on IMDb → -
03
Over the Garden Wall
Won 2 Emmys
animation · short · adventure · comedy · drama · family · fantasy · horror · mystery
Two brothers, Wirt and Greg, find themselves lost in the Unknown; a strange forest adrift in time. With the help of a wise old Woodsman and a foul-tempered bluebird named Beatrice, Wirt and Greg must travel across this strange land, in hope of finding their way home. Join them as they encounter surprises and obstacles on their journey through the wood.
Why watch: If you want a strange, atmospheric mystery with animation, Over the Garden Wall is worth a look. Its blend of adventure, fantasy, horror, and mystery makes it appealing for viewers who like an unusual tone.
Directed by Nate CashCast Elijah Wood, Collin Dean, Melanie Lynskey, Christopher Lloyd, Samuel RameyAmazon Prime VideoHuluDisney PlusMore details on IMDb → -
04
The Institute
horror · mystery & thriller · science-fiction
When 14 year old genius Luke Ellis is kidnapped, he awakens at The Institute, a facility full of children who all got there the same way he did, and who are all possessed of unusual abilities. In a nearby town, haunted former police officer Tim Jamieson has come looking to start a new life, but the peace and quiet won’t last, as his story and Luke’s are destined to collide.
Why watch: If you like mystery stories with horror and science-fiction elements, The Institute may be a fit. The idea of a kidnapped genius at a facility full of unusual children sets up a tense premise.
Amazon Prime VideoMore details on IMDb → -
05
Neagley
action & adventure · crime · drama · mystery & thriller
Neagley, drawing from her experience with Jack Reacher and the 110 Special Investigators, embarks on a perilous mission to expose a sinister threat, risking her life to unravel the mystery.
Why watch: If you prefer crime-driven mysteries with an action edge, Neagley may appeal to you. Its synopsis points to a dangerous mission built around uncovering a sinister threat.
Directed by Phil Abraham, MJ Bassett, Gary Fleder, Sam HillCast Maria Sten, Greyston Holt, Adeline Rudolph, Jasper Jones, Matthew Del NegroAmazon Prime VideoFreeveeMore details on IMDb →
Not quite it? Ask WattaWatch for mystery on Amazon Prime Video →
-
06
Goosebumps
adventure · comedy · drama · fantasy · horror · mystery · thriller
Anything can turn spooky in this horror anthology series based on the best-selling books by master of kid horror, R.L. Stine. In every episode, see what happens when regular kids find themselves in scary situations, and how they work to confront and overcome their fears.
Why watch: If you enjoy anthology-style scares, Goosebumps offers short, spooky stories with mystery and thriller elements. It’s a strong pick if you like each episode to bring a fresh situation.
Directed by William Fruet, Ron Oliver, John Bell, Randy Bradshaw, Timothy BondCast R.L. Stine, Kathryn Short, Cody Jones, Scott Wickware, Hamille RustiaNetflixAmazon Prime VideoTubiMore details on IMDb → -
07
The Night Manager
Won 2 Emmys 12 nominations
crime · drama · mystery · thriller
Former British soldier Jonathan Pine navigates the shadowy recesses of Whitehall and Washington where an unholy alliance operates between the intelligence community and the secret arms trade. To infiltrate the inner circle of lethal arms dealer Richard Onslow Roper, Pine must himself become a criminal.
Why watch: If you want an espionage-flavored mystery, The Night Manager is a strong option. Its crime, drama, mystery, and thriller mix suits viewers who like secretive power networks and undercover tension.
Directed by Susanne Bier, Georgi Banks-DaviesCast Tom Hiddleston, Hugh Laurie, Olivia Colman, Alistair Petrie, Michael NardoneAmazon Prime VideoMore details on IMDb → -
08
Supernatural
3 Emmy nominations
drama · fantasy · horror · mystery · thriller
When they were boys, Sam and Dean Winchester lost their mother to a mysterious and demonic supernatural force. Subsequently, their father raised them to be soldiers. He taught them about the paranormal evil that lives in the dark corners and on the back roads of America ... and he taught them how to kill it. Now, the Winchester brothers crisscross the country in their '67 Chevy Impala, battling every kind of supernatural threat they encounter along the way.
Why watch: If you like long-running supernatural mysteries, Supernatural has plenty of that energy. The mix of horror, fantasy, and thriller elements makes it a good choice for fans of paranormal cases.
Directed by Robert Singer, Philip Sgriccia, John F. Showalter, Thomas J. Wright, Kim MannersCast Jared Padalecki, Jensen Ackles, Misha Collins, Mark Sheppard, Jim BeaverAmazon Prime VideoPeacock PremiumMore details on IMDb → -
09
Tales from the Crypt
7 Emmy nominations Outstanding Lead Actor in a Drama Series (1992)
comedy · crime · fantasy · horror · mystery · thriller
Cadaverous scream legend the Crypt Keeper is your macabre host for these forays of fright and fun based on the classic E.C. Comics tales from back in the day. So shamble up to the bar and pick your poison. Will it be an insane Santa on a personal slay ride? Honeymooners out to fulfill the "til death do we part" vow ASAP?
Why watch: If you enjoy anthology horror with a mystery twist, Tales from the Crypt is an easy pick. Its comedy, crime, fantasy, and thriller mix gives it a broad appeal for genre fans.
Directed by Russell Mulcahy, Elliot Silverstein, Robert Zemeckis, Richard Donner, Tom HollandCast John Kassir, Roy Brocksmith, Miguel Ferrer, Cam Clarke, Larry DrakeAmazon Prime VideoTubiMore details on IMDb → -
10
Yellowjackets
10 Emmy nominations 2x Outstanding Lead Actress in a Drama Series
drama · mystery · thriller
This equal parts survival epic, psychological horror story and coming-of-age drama tells the saga of a team of wildly talented high school girls soccer players who become the (un)lucky survivors of a plane crash deep in the remote northern wilderness. The series chronicles their descent from a complicated but thriving team to savage clans, while also tracking the lives they’ve attempted to piece back together nearly 25 years later.
Why watch: If you like survival stories with psychological mystery, Yellowjackets should be on your list. Its blend of drama, mystery, and thriller suits viewers who want secrets unfolding over time.
Directed by Ben Semanoff, Eva Sørhaug, Daisy von Scherler Mayer, Jeffrey W. Byrd, Bart NickersonCast Melanie Lynskey, Sophie Nélisse, Jasmin Savoy Brown, Sophie Thatcher, Samantha HanrattyNetflixAmazon Prime VideoParamount PlusMore details on IMDb → -
11
Person of Interest
1 Emmy nomination
action · crime · drama · mystery · sci-fi · thriller
John Reese, former CIA paramilitary operative, is presumed dead and teams up with reclusive billionaire Finch to prevent violent crimes in New York City by initiating their own type of justice. With the special training that Reese has had in Covert Operations and Finch's genius software inventing mind, the two are a perfect match for the job that they have to complete. With the help of surveillance equipment, they work "outside the law" and get the right criminal behind bars.
Why watch: If you prefer mystery with crime, action, and sci-fi elements, Person of Interest is a great fit. Its premise centers on preventing crimes through surveillance and intelligence work.
Directed by Chris Fisher, Richard J. Lewis, Frederick E.O. Toye, Jeffrey G. Hunt, Stephen SurjikCast Jim Caviezel, Kevin Chapman, Michael Emerson, Amy Acker, Taraji P. HensonAmazon Prime VideoPeacock PremiumMore details on IMDb → -
12
Chicago P.D.
action · crime · drama · mystery · thriller
A riveting police drama about the men and women of the Chicago Police Department's District 21 who put it all on the line to serve and protect their community. District 21 is made up of two distinctly different groups: the uniformed cops who patrol the beat and go head-to-head with the city's street crimes and the Intelligence Unit that combats the city's major offenses - organized crime, drug trafficking, high profile murders and beyond.
Why watch: If you enjoy police procedurals with ongoing mysteries, Chicago P.D. may be a strong choice. The crime and thriller focus suggests a steady stream of high-stakes cases.
Directed by Chad Saxton, Mark Tinker, Eriq La Salle, Nick Gomez, Carl SeatonCast Jason Beghe, Marina Squerciati, Patrick John Flueger, LaRoyce Hawkins, Amy MortonAmazon Prime VideoPeacock PremiumMore details on IMDb → -
13
The Expanse
drama · mystery · sci-fi
A thriller set two hundred years in the future following the case of a missing young woman who brings a hardened detective and a rogue ship's captain together in a race across the solar system to expose the greatest conspiracy in human history.
Why watch: If you like large-scale mysteries with a sci-fi setting, The Expanse is a good pick. Its missing-person premise and conspiracy angle make it appealing for viewers who enjoy layered storytelling.
Directed by Breck Eisner, Jeff Woolnough, Terry McDonough, Robert Lieberman, Kenneth FinkCast Steven Strait, Dominique Tipper, Wes Chatham, Shohreh Aghdashloo, Cas AnvarAmazon Prime VideoMore details on IMDb → -
14
Creepshow
fantasy · horror · mystery · thriller
A young boy's horror comic book comes to life in this anthology series of terrifying tales.
Why watch: If you want horror with anthology-style mystery, Creepshow delivers that mix. It’s a good fit if you like spooky tales that keep changing tone and scenario.
Directed by Greg Nicotero, John Harrison, Joe Lynch, Roxanne Benjamin, David BrucknerCast Carey Jones, Hannah Fierman, Kara Kimmer, David Alexander Kaplan, Fayna SanchezAmazon Prime VideoTubiAMC+More details on IMDb → -
15
Hannibal
1 Emmy nomination
crime · drama · horror · mystery · thriller
Both a gift and a curse, Graham has the extraordinary ability to think like his prey—he sees what they see, feels what they feel. But while Graham is pursuing an especially troubling, cannibalistic murderer, Special Agent Jack Crawford teams him with a highly respected psychiatrist – a man with a taste for the criminal minded – Dr. Hannibal Lecter.
Why watch: If you enjoy dark crime mysteries with horror elements, Hannibal is likely to suit you. Its thriller and psychological setup makes it a fit for viewers who like intense cat-and-mouse stories.
Directed by Michael Rymer, Guillermo Navarro, Vincenzo Natali, David Slade, Tim HunterCast Hugh Dancy, Mads Mikkelsen, Caroline Dhavernas, Laurence Fishburne, Scott ThompsonNetflixAmazon Prime VideoMore details on IMDb → -
16
The Lincoln Lawyer
crime · drama · mystery · thriller
Sidelined after an accident, hotshot Los Angeles lawyer Mickey Haller restarts his career - and his trademark Lincoln - when he takes on a murder case.
Why watch: If you want a legal mystery with crime and thriller elements, The Lincoln Lawyer is an easy recommendation. It centers on a murder case, so it should appeal to viewers who like courtroom tension.
Directed by Antonio Negret, Alonso Alvarez, Ted Humphrey, David Grossman, Ben Hernandez BrayCast Manuel Garcia-Rulfo, Angus Sampson, Becki Newton, Jazz Raycole, Neve CampbellNetflixAmazon Prime VideoMore details on IMDb → -
17
Batman: The Animated Series
Won 1 Emmy
animation · action · adventure · crime · family · mystery · sci-fi
Vowing to avenge the murder of his parents, Bruce Wayne devotes his life to wiping out crime in Gotham City as the masked vigilante "Batman".
Why watch: If you enjoy animated crime mysteries, Batman: The Animated Series is a standout choice. Its mix of action, adventure, crime, and mystery gives it broad appeal.
Directed by Kevin Altieri, Boyd Kirkland, Frank Paur, Dan Riba, Dick SebastCast Kevin Conroy, Efrem Zimbalist Jr., Bob Hastings, Loren Lester, Robert CostanzoAmazon Prime VideoMaxMore details on IMDb → -
18
Columbo
Won 13 Emmys 2x Outstanding Lead Actor in a Drama Series · 39 nominations
crime · drama · mystery · thriller
Columbo is a friendly, verbose, disheveled-looking police detective who is consistently underestimated by his suspects. Despite his unprepossessing appearance and apparent absentmindedness, he shrewdly solves all of his cases and secures all evidence needed for indictment. His formidable eye for detail and meticulously dedicated approach often become clear to the killer only late in the storyline.
Why watch: If you like classic detective work, Columbo is a natural fit. Its mystery and crime focus works well for viewers who enjoy careful clue-following and character-driven investigations.
Directed by Bernard L. Kowalski, Harvey Hart, James Frawley, Richard Quine, Leo PennCast Peter Falk, Mike Lally, Dianne Travis, Bruce Kirby, John FinneganAmazon Prime VideoTubiPeacock PremiumMore details on IMDb → -
19
Blue Lights
Won 1 BAFTA TV Award 4 nominations
crime · drama · mystery & thriller
Follows rookie police officers working in Belfast, a city in which being a frontline response cop comes with unique pressures and dangers.
Why watch: If you prefer grounded police drama with mystery and thriller elements, Blue Lights is worth considering. The Belfast setting and rookie-officer premise suggest a tense, character-focused watch.
Directed by Gilles Bannier, Jack Casey, Angela Griffin, Declan Lawn, Adam PattersonCast Sian Brooke, Katherine Devlin, Nathan Braniff, Martin McCann, Andi OshoAmazon Prime VideoMaxMore details on IMDb → -
20
Are You Afraid of the Dark?
drama · fantasy · horror · mystery · sci-fi · thriller
This spooky anthology series for kids recounts ghost stories told by the young members of the Midnight Society as they gather around a campfire. Each episode opens with members of the Midnight Society at their secret spot in the woods, where they prepare their fire and the night's storyteller announces the title of the his or her offering. However, the cameras soon leave the storyteller and switch to the tale being told.
Why watch: If you like spooky stories told in an anthology format, Are You Afraid of the Dark? is a strong pick. Its mystery, horror, and thriller genres make it a good match for fans of campfire-style scares.
Directed by D.J. MacHale, Ron Oliver, David Winning, Mark Soulard, Iain PatersonCast Ross Hull, Daniel DeSanto, Raine Pare-Coull, Jodie Resther, Jason AlisharanAmazon Prime VideoTubiMore details on IMDb →
Wrapping Up
From classic detective work to psychological suspense and horror-leaning mysteries, this roundup is built to help you narrow down what to watch next. You can come back when you want a grounded crime story, a supernatural case, or a more offbeat mystery with animation or anthology elements. Bookmark this page and check back often, because it’s updated regularly as new titles are added and recommendations shift. If you like having a quick way to compare tone, genre, and ratings in one place, this list is made for that.
Frequently Asked Questions
How often is this list updated?
We refresh this list regularly as titles are added or removed from streaming catalogs, so rankings and availability stay current.
Do I need an Amazon Prime Video subscription to watch these?
Yes. Every title on this list is currently available on Amazon Prime Video. Availability can change, so we recommend checking the streaming link on each title before you start watching.
How are these mystery shows ranked?
We rank by a combination of audience rating and current popularity, so you're seeing the mystery titles people are actually watching right now, not just an old fixed list.