12 Best Shows Like Talamasca: The Secret Order to Watch Next (2026)
Find shows like Talamasca: The Secret Order, with secret societies, witches, demons, and eerie sci-fi thrillers across 12 smart series picks.
If you’re searching for shows like Talamasca: The Secret Order, the best matches tend to mix secret societies, supernatural threats, and a little mystery or sci-fi intrigue. This list leans into that same mood with titles like Sanctuary: A Witch's Tale, The Sandman, Castle Rock, and Island, all of which explore strange worlds or hidden forces in very different ways. You’ll also find newer picks such as The Copenhagen Test, Cassandra, and Devil May Cry for viewers who want action with their fantasy. Whether you want witches, demons, monsters, or conspiracies, these series give you plenty of ways to keep the uncanny atmosphere going.
-
01
Sanctuary: A Witch's Tale
fantasy · thriller
Set in a contemporary world where witchcraft is real, the story takes place in the idyllic English town of Sanctuary, where for hundreds of years witches have lived peacefully, as valued members of society. Until now…
Why watch: If you enjoy witch-focused stories set in a modern setting, this is a natural fit. Its fantasy-thriller mix and small-town setup make it a good match for viewers who want supernatural tension without leaving the present day.
Directed by Justin Molotnikov, Lisa Mulcahy, Dathaí Keane, Hannah QuinnCast Elaine Cassidy, Hazel Doupe, Daniel Adegboyega, Stephanie Levi-John, Valerie O'ConnorAMC+More details on IMDb → -
02
The Copenhagen Test
action · fantasy · sci-fi
When an analyst discovers his eyes and ears have been hacked, he's drawn into a controlled world designed by his agency to draw out their enemies.
Why watch: If you like conspiracy-driven sci-fi with a fast-moving premise, this should be on your list. The blend of action, fantasy, and technology-driven suspicion gives it a sharp, paranoid edge.
Directed by Vincenzo Natali, Nima Nourizadeh, Kevin Tancharoen, Jet WilkinsonCast Simu Liu, Melissa Barrera, Sinclair Daniel, Brian d'Arcy James, Mark O'BrienPeacock PremiumMore details on IMDb → -
03
The Sandman
1 BAFTA TV Award nomination
drama · fantasy · horror · mystery · sci-fi
After years of imprisonment, Morpheus — the King of Dreams — embarks on a journey across worlds to find what was stolen from him and restore his power.
Why watch: If you want a richer fantasy world with mystery and horror elements, this is a strong choice. It suits viewers who like stories built around powerful beings, layered mythology, and journeys across worlds.
Directed by Jamie Childs, Andrés Baiz, Louise Hooper, Mairzee Almas, Mike BarkerCast Tom Sturridge, Vivienne Acheampong, Patton Oswalt, Nina Wadia, Souad FaressNetflixMore details on IMDb → -
04
Cassandra
drama · horror · sci-fi · thriller
A family moves into a vintage smart home and discovers that it's under the control of a virtual assistant — who will stop at nothing to keep them there.
Why watch: If you prefer eerie, contained sci-fi horror, this one is worth a look. The setup with a smart home and a controlling virtual assistant suggests a tense story rooted in thriller and horror ideas.
Directed by Benjamin GutscheCast Lavinia Wilson, Franz Hartwig, Mary Amber Oseremen Tölle, Elias Grünthal, Filip SchnackNetflixMore details on IMDb → -
05
Paradise
Won 1 Emmy 2x Outstanding Lead Actor in a Drama Series · 11 nominations
action · drama · thriller
The tranquility in a serene, wealthy community inhabited by some of the world's most prominent individuals explodes when a shocking murder occurs and a high stakes investigation unfolds.
Why watch: If you want a thriller with a polished, high-stakes atmosphere, this is a solid pick. Its crime-free premise still promises pressure, secrets, and an investigation that escalates fast.
Directed by Glenn Ficarra, John Requa, Hanelle M. Culpepper, Gandja Monteiro, Liza JohnsonCast Sterling K. Brown, Sarah Shahi, Nicole Brydon Bloom, Julianne Nicholson, Aliyah MastinHuluMore details on IMDb → -
06
Castle Rock
1 Emmy nomination
drama · fantasy · horror · mystery · sci-fi · thriller
Based on the stories of Stephen King, the series intertwines characters and themes from the fictional town of Castle Rock.
Why watch: If you enjoy dark, puzzle-box storytelling with fantasy, horror, and mystery mixed together, this stands out. It’s a good option for viewers drawn to stories centered on a strange town and interconnected characters.
Directed by Greg Yaitanes, Michael Uppendahl, Phil Abraham, Anne Sewitsky, Ana Lily AmirpourCast Bill Skarsgård, André Holland, Lizzy Caplan, Melanie Lynskey, Paul SparksNetflixHuluMore details on IMDb → -
07
Joko Anwar's Nightmares and Daydreams
drama · horror · mystery · sci-fi · thriller
Ordinary people encountering strange phenomenons that may be keys to the answer about the origin of our world and the imminent threat we will soon face.
Why watch: If you like anthology-style supernatural stories that lean into mystery and sci-fi, this is a fitting choice. It seems best for viewers who enjoy strange events with a larger-world explanation waiting underneath.
Directed by Ray Farandy Pakpahan, Randolph Zaini, Joko Anwar, Tommy DewoCast Sita Nursanti, Mark Camacho, Karl Graboshas, Julian Stamboulieh, Haydar SalishzNetflixMore details on IMDb → -
09
Island
action · adventure · drama · fantasy · horror · mystery · thriller
Jeju Island is taken over by evil spirits. An exorcist, priest, and chaebol heiress are fated to fight against evil spirits attempting to end the world. “They are stirring at last.”
Why watch: If you’re in the mood for a bigger genre mashup, this combines action, adventure, fantasy, horror, mystery, and thriller elements. The evil-spirits premise makes it a good pick for fans of apocalyptic supernatural stakes.
Directed by Kwang-Hyun ParkCast Kim Nam-gil, Lee Da-hee, Cha Eun-woo, Ko Du-shim, Heo Jung HeeAmazon Prime VideoMore details on IMDb → -
10
Countdown
crime · drama · thriller
When an officer with the Department of Homeland Security is murdered in broad daylight, LAPD detective Mark Meachum is recruited to a secret task force, alongside undercover agents from all branches of law enforcement, to investigate. But the hunt for the killer soon uncovers a plot far more sinister than anyone could have imagined, kicking off a race against time to save a city of millions.
Why watch: If you like law-enforcement thrillers with a wider conspiracy underneath, this is a strong choice. It should appeal to viewers who want a race-against-time plot with crime and thriller momentum.
Directed by Jonathan Brown, Lisa Robinson, Avi Youabian, Chris Grismer, Rashidi Natara HarperCast Jensen Ackles, Jessica Camacho, Violett Beane, Elliot Knight, Uli LatukefuAmazon Prime VideoFreeveeMore details on IMDb → -
11
Devil May Cry
animation · action · adventure · fantasy · mystery
When a mysterious villain threatens to open the gates of Hell, a devilishly handsome demon hunter could be the world's best hope for salvation.
Why watch: If you enjoy animated action with fantasy and mystery, this is an easy recommendation. The demon-hunter setup is especially appealing if you want a darker, supernatural adventure with a genre-forward feel.
Directed by Seung Woo Han, So Young Park, Mathieu Corbin, Jee Young Hong, Sun-Min KimCast Johnny Yong Bosch, Scout Taylor-Compton, Robbie Daymond, Ray Chase, Hoon LeeNetflixMore details on IMDb → -
12
The Imperfects
action · adventure · drama · fantasy · mystery · sci-fi
After an experimental gene therapy turns them into monsters, three twenty-somethings band together to hunt down the scientist responsible and force him to make them human again.
Why watch: If you’re interested in stories about people changed by science and then chasing answers, this fits well. Its mix of action, adventure, drama, fantasy, mystery, and sci-fi should suit viewers who like teams, experiments, and monster-adjacent stakes.
Directed by Mark Chow, Director X, Dennis Heaton, Mathias Herndl, Nimisha MukerjiCast Italia Ricci, Morgan Taylor Campbell, Rhianna Jagpal, Iñaki Godoy, Kyra ZagorskyNetflixMore details on IMDb →
Wrapping Up
This selection brings together fantasy, thriller, sci-fi, and action series that all tap into secrets, supernatural conflict, or high-stakes investigations. If you liked the idea of hidden worlds and dangerous organizations, there’s a good chance several of these will fit your next watch. Bookmark this page and come back whenever you want more options in the same lane. It’s updated regularly, so the list can keep growing as new titles arrive.
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes these shows similar to Talamasca: The Secret Order?
These picks were matched by tone, themes, and story style using a similarity model trained on plot synopses, genres, and cast — not just shared genre tags — so the connection runs deeper than a simple category match.