12 Movies Like Murder in the Cove You Need to Watch
Find gripping true-crime picks like Murder in the Cove, from Murder in the Heartland to Bodies in the Water, with documentaries, drama, and dark history.
If you’re searching for movies like Murder in the Cove, you’re probably after true-crime stories that mix investigation, grief, and a strong sense of place. This list brings together documentary-style picks and crime dramas that follow similar emotional beats, from Murder in the Heartland and Buried in the Backyard to Devil in the Ozarks and Murder in the Valleys. You’ll also find newer standouts such as Bodies in the Water and After the Bite, plus atmospheric titles like Devil in the Mountains. Whether you want courtroom tension, regional mystery, or a biography-driven angle, these selections keep the focus on real-world danger and the people left to piece it all together.
-
01
Murder in the Heartland
documentary · crime
Weaving harrowing narratives of quiet Middle American towns torn apart by provocative murders. Each town's tale is given life by the combined perspectives of its residents, who are more than just storytellers. They are also key witnesses to each of the crimes, and they hold critical clues to puzzles that not only have forever changed their lives but how they have come to view their once-idyllic hometowns.
Directed by Brenden Clark, Ari Mark, Phil LottCast Joel Searls, Blake Eli, Eric Laney, Natalie De Vincentiis, Jerry RectorHuluMax -
02
Buried in the Backyard
documentary · crime
True-crime stories about unfortunate victims found buried in the most unlikely of places -- the backyard.
Directed by Douglas Elford-Argent, Erik S. Weigel, Greg Francis, Bobby MunsterCast Sadie Medley, Kieran Harriman, Rhoda Pell, Amir Mo, Faith BarrettPeacock Premium -
03
Devil in the Ozarks
crime · documentary
A brazen sexual assault shocks a small town, but goes unsolved for 20 years, until a nearby murder produces a suspect with matching DNA.
Directed by John DorseyMax -
04
Murder in the Valleys
documentary
Filmed over a period of twelve months, Murder in The Valleys tells the story behind the largest and most exhaustive criminal investigation in Welsh history and its enduring repercussions. One night in June 1999, three generations of one family were brutally killed in the small village of Clydach, South Wales. For more than twenty years – and despite the conviction of a local builder - the case has deeply divided the community
Directed by Tom BarrowCast Phil Parry, Debra ThomasAMC+ -
05
Devil in the Mountains
documentary · crime
A man found stabbed and burned launches Lt. Joe Kenda on a manhunt. When the trail goes cold, Kenda connects the dots among a string of otherwise unrelated heartless murders leading him into his first and only search for a serial killer.
Cast Tommi Aleman, Andrew D. Erath, Neftali Hernandez, Carey Jones, Chris KestersonMax -
06
Bodies in the Water
documentary · crime
Haunting real-life mysteries that dive deep into the secrets of murder victims submerged in a watery grave.
Directed by Thomai HatsiosCast Ryan Benson, Imani Turner, Brian FlechsigMax -
07
After the Bite
documentary
Following a series of great white shark attacks that dominated the headlines, one Cape Cod community renegotiates its relationship with the marine environment. Local residents, fishermen, and environmentalists are forced to confront dramatic changes to their way of life. How far can we push nature before it bites back?
Directed by Ivy MeeropolCast Greg SkomalMax -
08
The Trial: A Murder in the Family
documentary · crime
In a pioneering series that reveals the inner workings of the legal system, a fictional murder case is tried in a real court, by eminent legal professionals and a jury of 12 members of the public.
Directed by Nick Holt, Kath MattockCast Michael Gould, Emma Lowndes, Kevin Harvey, Fern Deacon, Liam SargeantAmazon Prime VideoFreevee -
09
The Boy in the Woods
biography · drama · history
The remarkable true-life survival story of a Jewish boy hiding and being hunted in the forests of Nazi-occupied Eastern Europe.
Directed by Rebecca SnowCast Jett Klyne, Richard Armitage, David Kohlsmith, Katherine Fogler, Masa LizdekFreevee -
10
Kurt Vonnegut: Unstuck in Time
documentary
Recounting the extraordinary life of author Kurt Vonnegut, and the 25-year friendship with the filmmaker who set out to document it.
Directed by Robert B. Weide, Don ArgottCast John Irving, Eugene Roche, Michael SacksAMC+ -
11
Caught in the Net
documentary · crime
Gripping true stories of investigators entering the digital world to solve a brutal murder. In each case, detectives are up against a lack of physical clues, but digital trails left behind help lead them to the killers.
Directed by Bill Thomas, Simon Dales, Nicola MorganCast Jessica MarcinkoMax -
12
Blow the Man Down
comedy · crime · drama · mystery · thriller
While grieving for the loss of their mother, the Connolly sisters suddenly find they have a crime to cover up, leading them deep into the underbelly of their salty Maine fishing village.
Directed by Bridget Savage Cole, Danielle KrudyCast David Coffin, David Pridemore, Adam Wolf Mayerson, Mark S. Cartier, Meredith HolzmanAmazon Prime VideoFreevee
Wrapping Up
These recommendations work because they capture the same uneasy blend of crime reporting, human loss, and local history that made Murder in the Cove so compelling. From rural investigations to documentary accounts of shocking cases, each title offers a different way into the genre without losing that unsettling, fact-based pull. Bookmark this page and come back when you want another true-crime watchlist with a similar tone. We update it regularly, so there’s always something new to discover.
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes these movies similar to Murder in the Cove?
These picks were matched by tone, themes, and story style using a similarity model trained on plot synopses, genres, and cast — not just shared genre tags — so the connection runs deeper than a simple category match.
Related Guides
Last updated: September 7, 2026