12 Movies Like Mayday You Need to Watch
Searching for movies like Mayday? Explore 12 suspenseful picks across horror, sci-fi, mystery, fantasy, and drama, including Offseason and Freaks.
If you enjoyed Mayday and want more films that mix tension with strange, emotional, or otherworldly twists, this list has you covered. The picks move between horror, sci-fi, mystery, fantasy, and drama, so you can follow the mood that made the original stick with you. Start with Offseason for bleak survival dread, Before I Fall for a sharp time-loop drama, or Freaks if you want a quieter story that still keeps you on edge. Lucky, Risen, Mortal, and The Unholy each bring a different flavor of unease, from eerie suspense to supernatural conflict. Whether you want something grounded or something stranger, these recommendations keep the same uneasy energy without feeling repetitive.
-
01
Offseason
drama · fantasy · horror · mystery · sci-fi · thriller
Upon receiving a mysterious letter that her mother's grave has been vandalized, Marie travels to the desolate island town where she's buried. Just as she arrives, the island closes for the season, leaving Marie trapped in a nightmare.
Directed by Mickey KeatingCast Jocelin Donahue, Joe Swanberg, Richard Brake, Melora Walters, Jeremy GardnerAMC+ -
02
Before I Fall
drama · fantasy · mystery
Samantha Kingston has everything. Then, everything changes. After one fateful night, she wakes up with no future at all. Trapped into reliving the same day over and over, she begins to question just how perfect her life really was.
Directed by Ry Russo-YoungCast Zoey Deutch, Halston Sage, Logan Miller, Kian Lawley, Elena KampourisStarz -
03
Lucky
drama · fantasy · horror · thriller
May, a self help author with all the answers, suddenly finds herself stalked by a masked man who mysteriously reappears every night. Even when she kills him. May struggles to get help from the people around her as she fights to stay alive. Is this paranoia, or is she doomed to accept her new reality?
Directed by Natasha KermaniCast Brea Grant, Leith M. Burke, Dhruv Uday Singh, Hunter C. Smith, Chivonne MichelleAMC+ -
04
Freaks
drama · fantasy · mystery · sci-fi · thriller
Kept locked inside the house by her father, 7-year-old Chloe lives in fear and fascination of the outside world, where Abnormals create a constant threat—or so she believes. When a mysterious stranger offers her a glimpse of what's really happening outside, Chloe soon finds that while the truth isn't so simple, the danger is very real.
Directed by Zach Lipovsky, Adam B. SteinCast Emile Hirsch, Bruce Dern, Grace Park, Amanda Crew, Lexy KolkerAmazon Prime VideoPeacock Premium -
05
Risen
drama · sci-fi · thriller
Disaster unfolds when a meteor strikes a small town, turning the environment uninhabitable and killing everything in the surrounding area. Exobiologist Lauren Stone is called to find answers to the unearthly event. As she begins to uncover the truth, imminent danger awakens and it becomes a race against time to save mankind.
Directed by Eddie AryaCast Zahlee Moore, Izzy Bridger, Lily Brown Griffiths, Dominic Stone, Jay KallawayAmazon Prime Video -
06
Mortal
action · adventure · drama · fantasy · mystery
A young boy must discover the origins of his extraordinary powers before he is captured by authorities hell-bent on condemning him for an accidental murder.
Directed by André ØvredalCast Nat Wolff, Priyanka Bose, Iben Akerlie, Arthur Hakalahti, Ravdeep Singh BajwaAmazon Prime VideoFreevee -
07
The Unholy
drama · horror · mystery · thriller
Alice is a young hearing-impaired girl who, after a supposed visitation from the Virgin Mary, is inexplicably able to hear, speak and heal the sick. As word spreads and people from near and far flock to witness her miracles, a disgraced journalist hoping to revive his career visits the small New England town to investigate. When terrifying events begin to happen all around, he starts to question if these phenomena are the works of the Virgin Mary or something much more sinister.
Directed by Evan SpiliotopoulosCast Jeffrey Dean Morgan, Cricket Brown, William Sadler, Katie Aselton, Cary ElwesHulu -
08
Arrival
drama · mystery · sci-fi
Taking place after alien crafts land around the world, an expert linguist is recruited by the military to determine whether they come in peace or are a threat.
Directed by Denis VilleneuveCast Amy Adams, Jeremy Renner, Forest Whitaker, Michael Stuhlbarg, Mark O'BrienParamount Plus -
09
The Wasteland
drama · horror · mystery
Lucía and her son live isolated from society in a flat place where there’s practically no life. The small family unit formed by mother and son hardly ever receives visitors, and their goal is to lead a quiet existence. At first they succeed, but the appearance of a mysterious, violent creature that starts stalking their small house will put the relationship that unites them to the test.
Directed by David CasademuntCast Inma Cuesta, Roberto Álamo, Alejandra Howard, Asier Flores, Víctor BenjumeaNetflix -
10
Homebound
drama · horror · mystery
A young woman arrives at the home of her new husband's estranged family to find the children behaving in increasingly unnerving ways.
Directed by Sebastian GodwinCast Aisling Loftus, Tom Goodman-Hill, Raffiella Chapman, Lukas Rolfe, Hattie GotobedAMC+ -
11
She Dies Tomorrow
drama · fantasy · horror · mystery & thriller
Amy is ravaged by the notion that she is going to die tomorrow, which sends her down a dizzying emotional spiral. When her skeptical friend Jane discovers Amy’s feeling of imminent death to be contagious, they both begin bizarre journeys through what might be the last day of their lives.
Directed by Amy SeimetzCast Kate Lyn Sheil, Jane Adams, Kentucker Audley, Katie Aselton, Chris MessinaAmazon Prime Video -
12
Wildling
drama · fantasy · horror · thriller
A young woman held in captivity discovers the realities of truth and lies in the outside world.
Directed by Fritz BöhmCast Bel Powley, Brad Dourif, Liv Tyler, Collin Kelly-Sordelet, James Le GrosAMC+
Wrapping Up
This roundup is built for viewers who liked the blend of suspense, mystery, and emotional pressure in Mayday and want more films with that same restless edge. From haunting stories like Offseason and The Unholy to genre-bending choices such as Freaks and Mortal, there’s plenty here to match different tastes. Use it as a starting point, then come back when you want another suggestion that fits your mood. We update this page regularly, so it’s worth bookmarking for your next watchlist refresh.
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes these movies similar to Mayday?
These picks were matched by tone, themes, and story style using a similarity model trained on plot synopses, genres, and cast — not just shared genre tags — so the connection runs deeper than a simple category match.
Related Guides
Last updated: September 16, 2026