12 Best Movies Like Allegedly with Ellison Barber to Watch Next (2026)
Explore documentaries and crime titles with investigation, mystery, and real-case focus for fans of Allegedly with Ellison Barber and similar true-crime stories.
If you’re searching for movies like Allegedly with Ellison Barber, you’re probably after true-crime stories that stay focused on investigations, people, and the facts behind disturbing cases. This list brings together documentaries and crime titles that lean into journalism, detective work, and unsolved or hard-to-shake mysteries. Start with The Death Investigator with Barbara Butcher, American Detective with Lt. Joe Kenda, and Down the Hill: The Delphi Murders Podcast if you want a strong investigative angle. For cases shaped by obsession, suspicion, or a wider historical backdrop, The Lady of Silence: The Mataviejitas Murders, Lover Stalker Killer, and World's Most Notorious Killers are smart places to go next.
-
01
The Widower: 'Til Death Do Us Part
documentary · crime
A journalist and a detective uncover the truth about a killer whose charm masked a trail of failed marriages and suspicious deaths.
Why watch: If you like journalist-led true crime with a case built around charm, suspicion, and investigation, this one should fit well. The documentary-crime mix makes it a natural next pick.
Directed by Chris SmithNetflixMore details on IMDb → -
02
The Lady of Silence: The Mataviejitas Murders
documentary · crime · history · mystery
Between 1998 and 2005, a wave of murders targeting elderly women hit Mexico City, triggering the hunt for — and capture — of a most unlikely suspect.
Why watch: If you enjoy true crime with a historical angle, this title may appeal to you. Its blend of documentary, crime, history, and mystery gives it a broader case-study feel.
Directed by María José CuevasCast Ted Bundy, Jeffrey Dahmer, Aileen Wuornos, John Wayne GacyNetflixMore details on IMDb → -
03
Down the Hill: The Delphi Murders Podcast
documentary · crime
Down the Hill: The Delphi Murders Podcast is a true crime podcast that examines the murders of Abigail Williams and Liberty German in the small town of Delphi, Indiana. The program is hosted by Andrew Iden and Barbara MacDonald who discuss the investigation and the effort to find the killer.
Why watch: If you want a podcast-style investigation that stays close to the details of a real murder case, this is a strong choice. It’s a good match for viewers who like step-by-step case breakdowns.
Cast Andrew Iden, Barbara MacDonaldMaxMore details on IMDb → -
04
Untold
crime · horror · thriller
TV journalist Vivian Vera hosts "Untold" documentary series. After a traumatic story investigation, strange events plague her and her crew, forcing her to confront her past secrets to uncover the truth.
Why watch: If you like crime stories that add horror and thriller elements to the investigation, this one stands out. Its premise also centers on a TV journalist, which may appeal if you like media-driven true-crime setups.
Directed by Roderick CabridoCast Jodi Sta. Maria, Joem Bascon, Juan Karlos Labajo, Gloria Diaz, Mylene DizonNetflixMore details on IMDb → -
05
Lover Stalker Killer
documentary · crime
In this twisting documentary, a mechanic tries online dating for the first time and meets a woman who takes romantic obsession to a deadly extreme.
Why watch: If you’re drawn to documentaries about obsession that turns dangerous, this is a good pick. It stays within the crime genre and focuses on a relationship that escalates in a serious way.
Directed by Sam HobkinsonCast Jessica N Johnson, Chris Maher, Katie OttenNetflixMore details on IMDb → -
06
Running with the Devil: The Wild World of John McAfee
documentary · crime
Through raw, revealing footage and interviews with fugitive tech pioneer John McAfee, this documentary uncovers new layers of his wild years on the run.
Why watch: If you want a crime documentary with a more unusual, character-driven subject, this title may interest you. It follows a fugitive tech figure through raw footage and interviews rather than a standard case format.
Directed by Charlie RussellCast Neil Cavuto, Janice Dyson, Greg Gutfeld, Larry King, Scott PelleyNetflixMore details on IMDb → -
07
The Death Investigator with Barbara Butcher
documentary · crime
The first true-crime series told through the eyes of Barbara Butcher, one of the most seasoned and respected Death Investigators to work in New York. After more than 20 years in the field, Butcher will unpack the stories behind some of the most compelling murders of our times - revealing that the keys to solving the case are often contained in the wealth of information held by the crime scene and the body that lies within it.
Why watch: If you like true crime told from the perspective of an experienced investigator, this is likely a strong fit. The focus on crime scenes and the work of a death investigator gives it a detailed, procedural feel.
Directed by Bruno BahunekCast Matt Combs, Megan Ridge, Emonnee Smith, Joseph R. Himes, L.A. WilsonPeacock PremiumMore details on IMDb → -
08
Me Hereafter
documentary · crime
A gripping true crime series following murder investigations. Combining investigative footage, interrogation videos, dramatic reenactments and interviews, it gives voice to victims as detectives uncover the truth.
Why watch: If you enjoy murder investigations told through multiple kinds of evidence and interviews, this one is worth a look. It also gives victims a voice, which may appeal if you like a more grounded approach.
Directed by Andy Awes, Ben KruegerCast Todd Sinkewich, Ryan Soule, Mark Har, Ian Forsyth, Tina ZimmerHuluMore details on IMDb → -
09
Killer Britain with Dermot Murnaghan
documentary · crime
British true crime documentary series in which the vastly experienced newsreader explores some British murder stories filled with dedicated detectives, intrigue and chilling story lines of homicide and hate.
Why watch: If British true crime cases and experienced-host storytelling are your thing, this series fits that lane well. It focuses on murder stories, detectives, and chilling case material.
Cast Dermot MurnaghanFreeveeMore details on IMDb → -
10
True Crime Story: Citizen Detective
documentary · crime
The gripping stories of everyday citizens who have solved or are attempting to solve a murder. Each episode focuses on an individual citizen detective – or a group working together – and the case that they’re consumed by, unpacking the details of the case and exploring the psyches of those who simply need to know what happened and why?
Why watch: If you’re interested in how ordinary people become deeply involved in a case, this is a natural pick. It adds a citizen-detective angle that sets it apart from more standard crime documentaries.
Cast Madison Taylor McConvilleAMC+More details on IMDb → -
11
American Detective with Lt. Joe Kenda
documentary · crime
Joe Kenda trades in his own case files to bring viewers astounding investigations from across the country, with each episode featuring a different homicide detective whose tireless efforts helped put a killer behind bars and bring justice for the victim.
Why watch: If you like homicide investigations led by a respected detective, this one should be near the top of your list. Its episode-by-episode format works well for viewers who enjoy straightforward case coverage.
Directed by Jeffrey Woods, Lauren J. Przybyszewski, Brian Peery, Christopher Mitchell, J. FisherCast Dustin Bolt, Jay Heselschwerdt, Andrew D. Erath, Micah Strange, André WilkersonHuluMaxMore details on IMDb → -
12
World's Most Notorious Killers
documentary · crime
Discover the chilling stories of five renowned international murder cases, featuring firsthand accounts from individuals close to each case and those seeking justice.
Why watch: If you want a global true-crime collection with firsthand accounts and a justice-focused angle, this series may suit you. It’s a good choice for viewers who like multiple cases in one documentary format.
Directed by Hugo Berkeley, Tom PollockCast Will Bayliss-Brown, Jose Tarouca, Maisie Shiplee, Mark MckeownPeacock PremiumMore details on IMDb →
Wrapping Up
These picks are a good fit if you want more of the same serious, case-driven energy and a mix of crime, documentary, history, mystery, and even a little horror-leaning tension. Whether you prefer journalist-led reporting, detective perspectives, or stories centered on real investigations, there’s plenty here to explore. Bookmark this page and come back whenever you want another true-crime watchlist, because it is updated regularly.
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes these movies similar to Allegedly with Ellison Barber?
These picks were matched by tone, themes, and story style using a similarity model trained on plot synopses, genres, and cast — not just shared genre tags — so the connection runs deeper than a simple category match.